I'm queue-skipping this because the other one scares me. Yours I can handle. I'm auto-adjusting depths.
I'm familiar with Maryland soils, so we can say you have a sandier soil with silt for your locale. Your ME of around 11 supports that.
pH 7.0: Kind of a useless number but people expect it.
We discuss this under calcium, magnesium, and potassium below a lot more.
OM 5.9%: Excellent! Keep it up. Certainly mulch mow and mow your leaves, but no special effort is required.
Sulfur 32: Normal. Higher OM usually means higher sulfur, as it does here.
Phosphorus 76: Low. I'd like to see 200 or a little higher with your pH, so I've made some recommendations below. This does lead to a weaker lawn, so I can see why you have some problems. We'll use a starter feritlizer to slowly change this number over the course of several years. A good starter features a second number around the same as the first number (like 18-24-6 or 22-20-5 or 20-20-3 or something like that. Those are just examples and yours won't look the same--just get the cheapest, they're all the same).
Calcium 74.6%: Right in the middle of the curve, and nice. It's contributing a lot toward your 7.0 pH, which is a tad high, but certainly not a problem.
Magnesium 15.6%: Right in the middle again and yadda yadda.
Potassium 4.2%: Do I need to say it? I do like a higher potassium and it's not as much influence on the pH, so it's not a big deal.
Sodium 1.2%: Sodium is a hair high, but it's not outrageous. Just keep an eye on it; we can get rid of it at the cost of adding more calcium. In this case, that would actually lower your pH a hair.
Most of your minor elements are just fine, although boron could use a tap. Check the Micronutrient Application Guide under the FAQs and see if you're comfortable with it. If you are, let's go with an initial adjustment of 3 Tbsp of 20 Mule Team Borax (laundry aisle at the grocery store!) to get you comfortable with doing it. That's not going to do any harm even if you make a pretty severe mistake, and the lawn could also use the iron. I'll put it in as "If you're comfortable" in the recommendations.
Recommendations:
May 25: Feed the lawn with any starter fertilizer at bag rate. If you're comfortable with the idea, apply 3 Tbsp 20 Mule Team Borax via Milo carrier using the Micronutrient Application Guide.
September 1: Feed the lawn with any starter fertilizer at bag rate.
October 1: Feed the lawn with any starter fertilizer at bag rate.